Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies – 12 Pack

These start with oversized moist devil’s food chocolate cake made with the finest ingredients including European chocolate, fresh buttermilk, local eggs, and fragrant vanilla, which are jammed with peanut butter cream filling. No cream cheese or marshmallow fluff, only made-from-scratch, pure ingredients.

Holly Holleran spent years as a professional polo coach, but she couldn’t escape the draw of her favorite childhood treat: whoopie pies. Growing up in western Pennsylvania, she spent lots of time in the bakery run by her grandmother, nicknamed Tico. The family bakery first opened its doors in 1939, and when she founded Tico’s Whoopies, Holly resurrected many of her grandmother’s original recipes. Her whoopie pies are handmade by Amish bakers daily using only fresh, wholesome ingredients.